Michigan Democratic Senate nominee Abdul El-Sayed is under fire for a comment made in a 2020 documentary clip where he expressed disdain for Mackinac Island, one of the state’s most beloved vacation spots. The remarks resurfaced in The Midwesterner’s story, prompting reactions on social media.
During his unsuccessful run for governor, El-Sayed walked through Mackinac Island, describing his dislike for the picturesque location situated in Lake Huron between Michigan’s Upper and Lower peninsulas. Despite his distaste, he noted that if he were to win, the governor’s summer residence on the island would be used as his summer home.
“I hate Mackinac so much,” El-Sayed stated, sparking controversy among Michigan residents who cherish the iconic island.
The comment sparked a flurry of conservative criticism online. Federalist editor-in-chief Mollie Hemingway accused El-Sayed and other Democrats of loathing America. Outkick founder Clay Travis and former Trump advisor Steve Cortes also expressed disbelief, citing the island’s beauty and significance.
Commentary Magazine editor John Podhoretz and National Republican Senatorial Committee spokesperson Sarah Gallagher shared similar sentiments, suggesting El-Sayed’s views reflect a disconnect with Michiganders.
“Abdul speaks fondly of his Egyptian summers yet he shows utter disdain for one of Michigan’s most beautiful summer destinations,” former Michigan GOP gubernatorial candidate Tudor Dixon remarked. Dixon argued that a representative must respect local heritage to effectively serve.
Criticism intensified as end Wokeness, a conservative influencer account, labeled Mackinac as the most American place in Michigan. Responses varied, with journalist Brad LaPlante defending El-Sayed’s comments, arguing they were taken out of context. LaPlante explained El-Sayed was critiquing the exclusive nature of the island’s annual policy conference.
Mackinac Island is unique for its ban on motor vehicles since the 1890s, allowing visitors to explore by foot, bicycle, or horse-drawn carriages. The island is known for its Victorian homes, historic hotels, and famous fudge shops, attracting over a million visitors worldwide each summer. Landmarks such as the Grand Hotel and Fort Mackinac contribute to its historical and cultural value.
Despite the backlash, El-Sayed responded to a post, challenging the notion of Mackinac as the most “American place in MI” due to its vehicle ban. Fox News Digital attempted to reach El-Sayed’s campaign for comment, but received no response.
Andrew Mark Miller, a reporter with Fox News, covered the story in detail. Follow him on Twitter @andymarkmiller and send tips to [email protected].

Leave a Reply