Newly released FBI records have highlighted the extent of China’s political influence efforts in the United States, focusing on a case involving former California Representative Eric Swalwell. During a 2015 interview with the FBI, Swalwell acknowledged having ‘physical relations’ with Christine Fang, also known as Fang Fang, while she campaigned for him as an unpaid volunteer. This information comes from documents shared by the White House Government Transparency Task Force.
Fang’s involvement with Swalwell underscores the sophisticated methods of Chinese intelligence, which includes the use of sex, money, and power. Although the FBI found no evidence that Fang obtained classified information from Swalwell, her activities underscored a concerning pattern of attempted influence at the grassroots level in American politics.
Swalwell’s Involvement with Fang
Fang enrolled at a Bay Area university in 2011 and became involved in local politics through Asian American civic groups. These groups helped her connect with up-and-coming politicians, such as then-councilman Swalwell. She was initially recruited by the FBI under the codename ‘Rusty Thumbs’ before becoming the subject of a counterintelligence operation known as ‘Freshman Fifteen.’ Authorities suspected her ties to Chinese intelligence and potential violations of U.S. election law through illegal straw donations.
Swalwell, who entered Congress in 2013, was cleared of suspicion by both the FBI and the House Ethics Committee. He stated he ceased contact with Fang after being informed of her foreign influence tactics. However, the case impacted him years after its public revelation in 2020. In April, Swalwell ended his campaign for California governor and resigned from Congress amid allegations of sexual misconduct, which he denies.
China’s Broader Strategy
Beijing’s efforts target rising political figures as part of a strategy to secure sympathizers in high-level positions within U.S. politics. Chinese intelligence casts a wide net, crossing party lines, to identify individuals potentially supportive of Chinese interests.
Experts suggest Western governments, with their separation of powers, are particularly vulnerable to public influence strategies. Unlike registered lobbying, these activities are deliberately opaque. While many targets may never hold significant power, the potential return outweighs the risk, making it a viable component of state espionage.
Additional Cases and Challenges
The complexity of democratic systems like those in the U.S. and the UK provides China opportunities to advance its influence efforts. An investigation linked over $1 million in U.S. political donations to groups affiliated with the Chinese Communist Party, though no illegal activity was found.
Similar cases have emerged elsewhere. In New York, charges against Governor Kathy Hochul’s former chief of staff Linda Sun allege unregistered foreign agent activities on China’s behalf. Sun and prosecutors remain locked in a legal battle since 2024.
In the UK, MI5 warned parliamentarians about Christine Lee, a lawyer reportedly funneling donations to politicians for the Chinese Communist Party. Additionally, Chinese businessman Yang Tengbo faced a travel ban for trying to foster connections between Chinese officials and prominent Britons.
Cautions and Criticisms
U.S. intelligence emphasizes avoiding blanket suspicion towards Chinese Americans, who may also fall victim to Chinese influence efforts. The Chinese leadership could exploit societal divisions and Western political systems, where proving espionage is challenging.
Swalwell’s attorneys previously requested the FBI not to release documents related to Fang Fang, fearing they would become weapons against Democrats. Despite these concerns, the key takeaway remains: China is strategically navigating the U.S. political framework long-term.
Leave a Reply