Baking Myths Debunked: Loud Noises and Flat Cakes

If you’ve been cautiously avoiding noise while baking, you’re not alone. Many fear that loud sounds in the kitchen will lead to a flat cake. But is this belief based on fact?

Expert Opinion

Cordon-Bleu-trained pastry chef Andrea Boudewijn asserts that loud noises don’t cause cakes to fall. “Yes, it’s a myth! Sound itself can’t make a baking cake fall unless it’s loud enough to cause a prolonged vibration near the cake,” she says. Air impact from slamming an oven door can affect the cake, but ingredients and mixing methods usually determine a cake’s sturdiness.

Origins of the Myth

The belief that noise can ruin a cake’s rise has persisted for generations. It’s believed to originate from soufflé-making practices in France. Soufflés need delicate handling, and slamming an oven door can ruin their rise. Misattributing the drop to noise instead of oven impact may have led to this misconception.

Real Causes of Flat Cakes

Flat cakes are generally caused by issues with ingredients or mixing methods:

Insufficient dry ingredients prevent the batter from supporting the liquid’s weight.
Using incorrect leavening agents can leave the cake in a liquid state.
Over-mixing makes carbonated liquids like Champagne or stout release fizz, causing the center to collapse.
Whipping rather than blending the batter can introduce excess air, making it unstable.

Preventing Flat Cakes

Boudewijn advises the following techniques to achieve desirable cake results:

Handle the batter gently, avoiding high-speed mixing.
Keep the oven door closed to maintain consistent heat.
Verify measurements to ensure ingredient accuracy.

Essential Baking Tools

Feel at ease during the baking process with recommended tools from Boudewijn:

KitchenAid Artisan Series Stand Mixer: Known for reliability, with multiple speed settings and versatile attachments.
Pyrex Measuring Cup Set: Offers durable construction with clear markings.
Amazon Basics Silicone Spatula Set: Comes in different sizes, heat-resistant and non-scratch.
USA Pan Bakeware Square Cake Pan: Durable, non-stick, and easy to clean aluminum steel construction.
OXO Good Grips Measuring Spoons: Affordable, color-coded, and includes several sizes.
Ozeri Digital Kitchen Scale: Features an easy-to-read display and compact design.
Cuisinart Chef’s Classic Sauce Pan: Suitable for high temperatures and resists sticking.
Cuisinart Mini Prep Plus Food Processor: Compact with essential controls and a powerful motor.
Webcake Cake Spatula Set: Essential for detailed cake decorating with durable stainless steel blades.
Ateco Wunderbag Decorating Bag: Reliable for leak-proof piping and repeated use.
Humbee Chef Serrated Cake Knife: Ensures smooth and even cake slices.

Prices are subject to change. For deals, check out our Daily Deals and sign up for the BestReviews weekly newsletter. Affiliate links may generate commission.